Author Blog

Before You Argue About God, Agree on the Word Proof

Most arguments about God fail before they begin, because the two sides mean different things by one word. A cryptographer’s rule for what counts as proof.

I have watched a great many arguments about God, and I have been in more than my share. Most of them fail before they start, and they fail over a single word.

The word is proof.

The Word I Used Without Defining

For years I demanded proof of God and never once stopped to say what I meant by it. If you had pressed me, I would have discovered that I was asking for something I accepted nowhere else in my life.

There are two very different things a person can mean. One is absolute certainty, the kind found in a mathematical theorem, where doubt is not merely unreasonable but impossible. The other is enough evidence that a fair-minded person would decide. That second standard is how juries reach verdicts, how historians establish that Caesar crossed the Rubicon, and how you concluded that the person you married loved you.

If one side of a conversation means the first and the other means the second, they can talk until midnight and never meet.

How a Cipher Earns Trust

My own field taught me which standard fits real questions. Nobody proves that a cipher is unbreakable in the way a theorem is proved. What we do is attack it. We publish it and invite the best minds to look for the crack, from every angle, for years. Only a code that survives long, determined attack earns our trust. The trust is not blind. It is the residue of every attack that failed.

That is how I treated the question of God. For twelve years I went at it the way you go at a cipher, looking for the weak point. I expected the faith my father died holding to break.

It did not break. And one day I had to be honest about what that meant. I had been applying a standard to God that I applied to nothing else, and even under that unfair standard the case had held.

A Better Opening Question

So before the next argument, try a different first move. Do not open with your best objection or your best evidence. Ask the other person, kindly, what would count. If the answer is “nothing could,” you have learned that the disagreement is not about evidence. If the answer is specific, you now have something real to examine together.

And ask yourself the same thing. Scripture does not flatter a faith that fears examination. “Prove all things; hold fast that which is good” (1 Thessalonians 5:21). Test it. Attack it. See what is still standing afterward.

Your Turn

What would count as proof for you? Absolute certainty, or the kind of evidence on which you already stake everything else that matters? It is worth settling that with yourself before you settle anything else.


Get new articles by email

Subscribe and I will send you a short note whenever a new article is published on this site. No spam, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

I spent twelve years trying to prove God does not exist.

Get my free guide, 7 Questions That Broke My Atheism, plus The Evidence Room letter every Tuesday: one hard question, one piece of evidence, one true story.

I spent twelve years trying to prove God does not exist.

Get my free guide, 7 Questions That Broke My Atheism, plus The Evidence Room letter every Tuesday: one hard question, one piece of evidence, one true story.