Author Blog

What Darwin Admitted About His Own Theory, Part One

Modern voices are more certain about evolution than Darwin ever was. In his own words, the eye, the sterile insects, and a crowd of difficulties.

Before I wrote a word of this, I stopped and prayed for you. This article is not an attempt to pull you toward my faith or away from yours. It comes from something simpler: I love you, whether we agree or not. My Lord loves you deeply, and my love for you is a reflection of His. You may not believe He exists, and I respect that. But His love for you does not depend on your believing in Him. It is there regardless, steady and unconditional. Love outlasts disagreement, and faith, at its heart, is care for one another.

More certain than Darwin himself

Here is a paradox that has struck me for years. Today’s scientific conversation often expresses more certainty about evolutionary theory than Charles Darwin ever did. He spent decades building his framework, poured enormous effort into anticipating objections, and recorded a long list of reservations about his own work. His heirs present the theory as settled beyond reasonable question.

So let me walk through the difficulties Darwin himself acknowledged, in his own words, with each passage identified so you can check it. What troubled him sheds light on both the real strengths of his theory and the humility that ought to accompany anyone’s acceptance of it.

One of the most surprising things about On the Origin of Species is how much of it Darwin spent arguing against himself. Rather than tucking the problems into footnotes, he collected them, named them, and placed them at the center of his own book, admitting plainly how much some of them troubled him.

This point gets overstated in both directions, so let me be accurate. Darwin never doubted that living things had descended with modification from earlier forms; he held that conviction to the end of his life. What he confessed in print were specific difficulties in explaining how natural selection could have produced certain features of the living world, and those confessions came from his own pen.

“A crowd of difficulties”

Darwin gave an entire chapter of the Origin, Chapter VI, to what he called “Difficulties on Theory.” He opened it by granting that many objections would already have occurred to his reader, and that some weighed on him personally:

Some of them are so grave that to this day I can never reflect on them without being staggered; but, to the best of my judgment, the greater number are only apparent, and those that are real are not, I think, fatal to my theory.

That sentence sets the pattern for everything he did with his difficulties. Some staggered him, and he said so. Most, he argued, were only apparent, and the real ones could be survived. He was not conceding defeat; he was showing his work, with honesty and confidence in equal measure.

The eye

The most famous of these admissions concerns the eye, which Darwin discussed under the heading “Organs of extreme perfection and complication.” The line most often quoted, and most often cut short, reads:

To suppose that the eye, with all its inimitable contrivances for adjusting the focus to different distances, for admitting different amounts of light, and for the correction of spherical and chromatic aberration, could have been formed by natural selection, seems, I freely confess, absurd in the highest possible degree.

Alone, that sounds like surrender. The next sentence turns it around:

Yet reason tells me, that if numerous gradations from a perfect and complex eye to one very imperfect and simple, each grade being useful to its possessor, can be shown to exist; if further, the eye does vary ever so slightly, and the variations be inherited, which is certainly the case; and if any variation or modification in the organ be ever useful to an animal under changing conditions of life, then the difficulty of believing that a perfect and complex eye could be formed by natural selection, though insuperable by our imagination, can hardly be considered real.

Darwin raised the difficulty in order to answer it. Quote the first half without the second and you are quoting half of Darwin, which is a different thing. I say this as a creationist with no interest in winning by trimming a quotation.

His letters show what the argument cost him privately. In February 1860, a few months after the Origin appeared, he wrote to the botanist Asa Gray:

The eye to this day gives me a cold shudder, but when I think of the fine known gradations, my reason tells me I ought to conquer the cold shudder.

There is the man himself: a difficulty real enough to produce a cold shudder, and a reason he felt obliged to let overrule it. Not doubt about evolution, but tension between what his imagination recoiled from and what he thought the evidence required.

Instinct and the sterile insects

In Chapter VII, on instinct, Darwin made his sharpest confession of all. After allowing that many instincts could be raised as objections, he singled out one:

I will not here enter on these several cases, but will confine myself to one special difficulty, which at first appeared to me insuperable, and actually fatal to my whole theory.

The problem was the sterile worker castes of ants, bees, and other social insects. Natural selection works by preserving useful variations that an individual passes to its offspring. A sterile worker leaves no offspring. How could it have evolved a body and instincts so unlike those of the parents that produced it? Darwin reached for the strongest words he had: insuperable, and actually fatal.

Then he proposed a way through: selection, he reasoned, need not act only on the individual but could act on the family:

This difficulty, though appearing insuperable, is lessened, or, as I believe, disappears, when it is remembered that selection may be applied to the family, as well as to the individual, and may thus gain the desired end.

A century later that intuition received a formal mathematical footing in what biologists call kin selection, associated with W. D. Hamilton’s work in 1964. Call it a full answer or a partial one; the historical fact stands either way. Darwin named a difficulty he called fatal, in his own book.

Part two takes up the objection Darwin ranked gravest of all, the fossil record, then the peacock’s tail, the critics who forced revisions, and what these admissions do and do not show.


Get new articles by email

Subscribe and I will send you a short note whenever a new article is published on this site. No spam, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

I spent twelve years trying to prove God does not exist.

Get my free guide, 7 Questions That Broke My Atheism, plus The Evidence Room letter every Tuesday: one hard question, one piece of evidence, one true story.

I spent twelve years trying to prove God does not exist.

Get my free guide, 7 Questions That Broke My Atheism, plus The Evidence Room letter every Tuesday: one hard question, one piece of evidence, one true story.