Look around the room you are sitting in. The chair did not have to exist. Someone made it, and before that someone grew the tree. Neither did the house, the street, or the planet under the street. Follow the thought outward and it does not stop. The sun did not have to exist. The galaxy did not. The universe itself, as far as anyone can tell, could have failed to be.
Things That Need a Reason
Philosophers have a plain word for this. They call such things contingent, which only means that they depend on something else for their existence. They are here, but they did not have to be.
Things of that kind need a reason for existing. We assume this every day without noticing. If you found a ball lying in the forest you would ask how it got there, and making the ball larger would not make the question go away. Make it the size of a planet, or the size of the cosmos, and the question is the same question.
A Chain Has to Hang From Something
So we explain one dependent thing by another, and that one by another. But a chain of dependent things, however long, cannot hold itself up. Picture a chandelier hanging from a chain. Each link is held by the link above it. Add as many links as you like. If there is no hook in the ceiling, nothing hangs at all.
The whole series of things that might not have existed needs something that is not like them. Something that does not borrow its existence. Something that cannot fail to be.
I resisted this for years. I looked for the flaw the way I would look for the flaw in a proof. What I kept finding was that every way out quietly gave existence to something for free: an eternal universe, a set of laws with nothing to be laws of, a brute fact that we are told not to ask about. Each of them is a hook in the ceiling under another name.
The Name at the Bush
Then read what Moses heard when he asked God for His name.
“And God said unto Moses, I AM THAT I AM: and he said, Thus shalt thou say unto the children of Israel, I AM hath sent me unto you” (Exodus 3:14).
Not a being who happened to exist, as you and I happen to exist. Not the largest link in the chain. A being whose very nature is to be. Every other thing has existence on loan. He is the one from whom it is borrowed.
A shepherd in the wilderness was handed, in four words, the answer that the long argument arrives at step by step.
Where This Leaves Us
This argument does not tell you everything about God. It does not tell you that He loves you or what He has done about your sin. For that you need the rest of the Book. But it does clear the ground. The question “why is there anything at all?” is not a childish question, and the answer is not nothing. You are here, and you did not have to be. That is worth thinking about before the day gets busy.
Get new articles by email
Subscribe and I will send you a short note whenever a new article is published on this site. No spam, and you can unsubscribe at any time.