A reader sent me a thoughtful objection. Two of the strongest sentences Jesus ever spoke, “Before Abraham was, I am” and “I am the way, the truth, and the life,” appear only in the Gospel of John. John was the last Gospel written. Perhaps it was rewritten. Perhaps the words were spoken only to friends. Perhaps the whole thing is legend.
I was glad to get the question, because it is four questions, and each one can be answered.
Is the Claim Only in John?
No. I agree that John was most likely written last. But the claim does not stand or fall with John.
In Mark, which most scholars treat as the earliest Gospel, Jesus tells a paralyzed man that his sins are forgiven. The scribes react at once: “Why doth this man thus speak blasphemies? who can forgive sins but God only?” (Mark 2:7). They understood what He was claiming.
At His trial the high priest asks, “Art thou the Christ, the Son of the Blessed?” and Jesus answers, “I am” (Mark 14:61, 62). The high priest tears his clothes and calls it blasphemy. That charge makes sense only if Jesus was claiming what belongs to God.
And the letters of Paul are older than any Gospel. Philippians 2 and Colossians 1 already speak of Christ in the language of deity. Nobody added this generations later.
Was John Rewritten?
There is no manuscript evidence that it was. The Bodmer papyri known as P66 and P75, generally dated to about AD 200, contain large portions of John, including chapter 8, and they read essentially as our Bibles read. A small fragment of John 18, called P52, is usually placed in the first half of the second century. The text we hold is the text the early Christians held.
Did He Say It Only to His Disciples?
John 14:6 was spoken in the upper room, yes. John 8:58 was not. Jesus said it in the temple, in public, to a hostile crowd. Look at what they did next: “Then took they up stones to cast at him” (John 8:59).
Why stones? Because “I am” echoes the name God gave Moses at the bush: “I AM THAT I AM” (Exodus 3:14). His enemies did not misunderstand Him. They understood Him perfectly and refused to believe Him. The stones are the proof of what the crowd heard.
Could It Still Be a Legend?
Legends need time. The Roman historian A. N. Sherwin-White argued that even two generations is too short for legend to bury a historical core.
Here the time was far shorter. In 1 Corinthians 15, Paul hands on a summary he had received very early: that the risen Christ was seen by more than five hundred people at once, most of whom were still alive when he wrote. That is not how a legend begins. It is an invitation to go and ask.
Then consider the first witnesses. Herod killed James the brother of John with the sword (Acts 12:2). Josephus, who was no Christian, records that James the brother of Jesus was stoned. People will die for what they believe is true. They do not die for what they know they invented.
The Question Left on the Table
A man who says “Before Abraham was, I am” has not left us the comfortable option of calling Him a fine moral teacher. He is either who He said He was, or He is deceiving, or He is deceived. He did not leave the matter hanging, because He walked out of His own grave.
“Jesus saith unto him, I am the way, the truth, and the life: no man cometh unto the Father, but by me” (John 14:6).
He is not only a figure of the past. The same voice that cleared the temple of its certainty that day is still asking each of us what we will do with Him.
Get new articles by email
Subscribe and I will send you a short note whenever a new article is published on this site. No spam, and you can unsubscribe at any time.