There is a sentence I hear in nearly every conversation with a modern atheist, usually within the first two minutes. “Atheism is not a claim. It is just a lack of belief.”
My chair lacks belief. So does the rock in my garden. So does a newborn. None of them has ever written a bestselling book about the courage it takes to reject God, and none of them has ever demanded that I defend my faith while refusing to defend anything in return.
The Most Popular Escape Hatch
The lack of belief line is the most popular escape hatch in modern atheism, and I understand why it is attractive. If atheism is merely an absence, then the atheist never has to carry anything. He stands at the door of every worldview with a clipboard, inspecting other people’s answers, and he never has to submit his own for inspection.
But watch what actually happens the moment he opens his mouth. The instant anyone says “there is no God,” or even “there is probably no God,” he has made a claim about all of reality. He has said something about what exists and what does not, about how the universe came to be, and about what a human being is. That is not an absence. It is a position, and a sweeping one.
The Homework That Comes With the Claim
Every claim about reality comes with homework. If there is no God, then I have some questions that need answers rather than shrugs.
- Where did the universe come from, and what caused it to begin?
- How did life arise from chemicals that were not alive?
- Where did reason come from, and why should I trust it?
- Where did morality come from, and why should it bind anyone?
The Christian has answers to those questions, and we are expected to defend them. Fair enough. We do. But the person who denies God has implicitly answered them too, and “I just lack belief” is a way of declining to show his work.
In Any Real Debate, That Is Forfeiting
Imagine a courtroom where one side presents its case and the other side simply says, “I lack belief in your case,” and sits down. No cross-examination, no competing account of the facts, no explanation of its own. Any judge would call that what it is. The side that refuses to argue has not won by default. It has forfeited.
The lack of belief line is not a position. It is a technique for attacking everyone else’s answers while never defending your own. If you make the claim, you carry the burden. There are no exemptions, not for me and not for you.
So the next time someone tells you atheism is just a lack of belief, agree with them cheerfully, and then point to the nearest rock. It lacks belief too. The difference is that the rock is not trying to persuade you of anything.
Get new articles by email
Subscribe and I will send you a short note whenever a new article is published on this site. No spam, and you can unsubscribe at any time.